← All interviews

Interview · Post-conviction review · Sentencing & prosecution

Adelina Iftene

Associate Professor of Law, Schulich School of Law, Dalhousie University; Criminal Justice Certificate Coordinator

https://youtu.be/tHUF3jj-ipU ↗

Chapters

Key moments from the conversation, each paired with a Korean case that raises the same question.

Chapter 01

Open at this moment ↗

Is prison more than the loss of freedom?

  • Sentencing has traditionally treated prison as the loss of liberty and little else.
  • Incarceration can damage health, family ties, job prospects and the chance of rejoining society.
  • Those costs fall hardest on prisoners who were already vulnerable.

The Korean parallel

Human Rights Commission prison inspection (2022)

After visiting ten Korean correctional institutions, the National Human Rights Commission reported too few specialist medical staff, thin mental healthcare and serious concerns about prisoners' access to treatment.

Chapter 02

Open at this moment ↗

Should punishment account for what happens inside prison?

  • The court that imposes a prison term and the administration that carries it out are usually kept apart.
  • Judges can pass sentence without knowing the conditions the person will actually live in.
  • If conditions undermine rehabilitation or add harm, the punishment served is not the punishment intended.

The Korean parallel

A prisoner's death and the 2024 findings

The National Human Rights Commission investigated the 2023 death of a 68-year-old prisoner with chronic physical and mental illness, and concluded that excessive disciplinary segregation and inadequate health protection had violated his rights.

Chapter 03

Open at this moment ↗

Can sentencing be fair if judges don't know prison conditions?

  • Many judges have little direct experience of prison or of what their sentences mean in practice.
  • That gap matters most for defendants with disabilities, serious medical needs or other vulnerabilities.
  • A judge who understands prison may treat these as mitigating; another may not see them at all.

The Korean parallel

Prison healthcare spending (2022)

The National Human Rights Commission found that medical spending per prisoner was about 12% of average national healthcare spending per person at the time of its investigation.

Next interview

Brandon Scheck →